If you own a corporation in Canada, one of the most common questions you’ll face is:
“Should I pay myself in salary, or in dividends?”
But here’s the catch – not all dividends are the same. The Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) has a long-term position splitting them into two categories (i) eligible and (ii) ineligible dividends. And if you don’t understand the difference, you could end up paying thousands more in taxes than necessary.
We would like to break it down for you in practical terms.
Eligible Dividends
Think of eligible dividends as the first-class ticket of corporate payouts. The eligible dividend regime is directed largely toward public corporations that pay higher corporate taxes and do not qualify for the small business tax deduction or private corporations with net income higher than the $500,000 small business deduction.
Eligible dividends come with an enhanced dividend tax credit, which is why they are taxed more favourably than non-eligible dividends.
Where do they come from?
They’re paid out of income that’s already been taxed at the general corporate rate (26.2% in Ontario), rather than the lower small business rate.
The benefit?
Because the company already paid more tax upfront, you personally get a bigger dividend tax credit. That means less tax owing on your personal return.
Common client question: “Why not just declare everything as eligible dividends if they’re better for tax?” The reality is you can only declare eligible dividends if your corporation has actually earned income taxed at the higher rate. Declaring them incorrectly risks CRA reassessments and penalties.
Ineligible Dividends
Also known as ordinary dividends, these are paid out of:
- Income taxed at the small business rate (about 12.2% in Ontario), or
- Funds tracked in the Low Rate Income Pool (LRIP).
Because the company paid less tax initially, you as the shareholder receive a smaller personal dividend tax credit. This means a higher effective personal tax rate on these dividends.
Case in point: One of our clients declared a $50,000 ineligible dividend and was surprised to learn that the personal tax bill was almost $6,000 higher compared to an eligible dividend.
Planning note: Business owners should reconsider the practice of bonusing out income in excess of the $500,000 small business limit. In many cases, leaving income in the corporation and paying dividends later results in an overall tax burden that is only modestly higher than the top marginal personal tax rate.
Compliance: More Than Just Moving Money
Declaring dividends isn’t just a bookkeeping exercise – it’s a legal event that comes with strict compliance requirements:
- Designation matters: You must label dividends as eligible or ineligible in your corporate records and on T5 slips. If you don’t, CRA defaults them to ineligible (the higher tax).
- Shareholder Notification: Dividend statements must specify the type of dividend declared.
- Corporate resolutions: Every dividend requires a formal resolution in the corporate minute book.
- T5 deadlines: File T5 slips with CRA by the end of February each year. Miss the deadline, and penalties apply.
Skipping steps exposes you to CRA audits, penalties, and unnecessary reassessments.
How Our Team Can Help
At Solvis Law, we’ve seen how even small errors in dividend declarations can snowball into costly problems.
This is a real-life example: A client came to us in 2024 after incorporating his business in 2019 through an online self-help service. He was given only generic paperwork and was unaware of his ongoing corporate obligations, including the need to maintain proper records. For several years, he declared dividends without passing the required resolutions. During a CRA review, these dividends were challenged, placing him at risk of reassessment and penalties.
We stepped in, updated and corrected his corporate records, brought the company back into compliance, and ultimately helped him avoid penalties.
Here’s how we can help you avoid the same pitfalls:
- Minute book upkeep: Every dividend requires a corporate resolution. We draft and maintain these records so they are always audit-proof.
- Proper designation: We ensure dividends are correctly classified in your records and T5 slips.
- Shareholder communication: Clear dividend statements protect both you and your shareholders.
- Peace of mind: With us handling the legal details, you can focus on running your business.
Understanding the difference between eligible and ineligible dividends is more than just decoding tax jargon. This difference can have a real impact on the tax efficiency and compliance. With the right planning and guidance, you can reduce unnecessary tax exposure, safeguard your business from CRA issues, and ensure your records remain audit-proof. If you have questions or would like tailored advice, contact Solvis Law today to book a consultation.
Disclaimer:
The information provided here is for general educational purposes only and does not constitute legal or tax advice. Dividend planning involves complex legal and accounting considerations that vary depending on your specific circumstances. We strongly recommend that you consult with a qualified accountant or CPA before making any decisions regarding the declaration or designation of dividends.
